Sunday, February 19, 2012

Breaking News: Lawsuit Charges L.A. County Supervisors Violated Brown Act

Zev Yaroslavsky   Mark Ridley-Thomas
Mike Antonovich      Don Knabe        Gloria Molina

Los Angeles, CA   County Supervisor Michael Antonovich is making an urgent plea to the California Lawmakers to pass legislation to allow the Board to hold private meetings with U. S. President Barack Obama and California Governor Jerry Brown. In this 3 minute video Antonovich explains the need to legalize "private meetings" that exclude the public and public comment.  Such meetings currently violate California’s long standing Ralph M. Brown Act that mandates all official meetings to be open to the public with opportunity for comment when the public’s business is being deliberated. 

 Lawsuit Filed Against County Board
This month the County Board of Supervisors became the target of a Superior Court Lawsuit filed by Californians Aware, a Sacramento based, non profit watchdog organization dedicated to preserving open and transparent government.  

According to the Verified Petition for Writ of Mandate and Injunction filed under Case No. BS135835  the Californians Aware lawsuit is seeking Declaratory Relief for Violations of the Ralph M. Brown Act for closed meetings held in September of 2011 that involved Governor Jerry Brown and the five members of the Board of Supervisors and others who may not have been authorized to attend or participate in legally held closed Board meetings.

Terry Francke, (left) is a highly respected legal expert on the California Ralph M Brown Act.  He is the General Counsel for Californians Aware.  He signed the Verified Petition under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California that the lawsuit and the allegations and exhibits from the public records are believed to be true and accurate. Over the years Francke has represented news organizations and citizen groups who have had difficulty obtaining public records and access to government meetings. Serving as co-counsel with Francke are Dennis Winston, President Californians Aware and .Kelly Avilas of La Verne, California. 

Supervisors Call For URGENT Closed Session
But the Board of Supervisors has posted this notice of a scheduled closed session on Wednesday, February 22, 2012 to discuss the lawsuit  and four other items.   The Board has not indicated what staff members may be present during the proposed five hour meeting.but there are five issues before them.

Judicial Conflict of Interest?
Apparently State Superior Court Judge Ann I Jones has not yet recognized the same urgency as the Board of Supervisors,for she has scheduled the first conference hearing on the lawsuit for July 6, 2012.   Although the County of Los Angeles is a party to this case, and Judge Jones has admitted receiving double benefits from the County of Los Angeles on top of her State salary and benefits, she has not recused herself from sitting on the case.  Like Judge Jones, all State Superior Court Judges in Los Angeles have been receiving double benefits from the County, these benefits were held to be illegal in Sturgeon v County of Los Angeles a landmark lawsuit won by the Judicial Watch public interest legal organization in 2008.   

Activists Encouraged By Lawsuit
Jon Nahhas is a Marina del Rey  resident and boating activist who has been critical of the Board of Supervisors for repeatedly violating the Brown Act while conducting the public's business. In particular the County's massive re-development projects on County-owned land in Marina del Rey.  Nahhas has complained that County residents have been prohibited from speaking on issues to be voted upon  by the Board  involving proposed developments .  He  told  Full Disclosure "the Californians Aware lawsuit comes at the most opportune time when the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors are continuing to ignore the parameters  of the Brown Act and conduct the people’s business in private. The federal government is already imposing sanctions on the County Probation Department and investigating several other County departments. The County Sheriff’s Department has been caught planting evidence and falsifying documents.  The Supervisors have been accused of tampering with the County’s Planning Divison employees.  Key documents in Los Angeles County Offices have gone missing and computers that would have stored the data have suddenly broken.  Many more scandals are slowly coming to the surface as the Board of Supervisors continue to deter public inquiry by limiting public speaking at Board Meetings.  Terry Francke and Californians Aware are forcing the County Supervisors to comply with our laws in California and hopefully moving them in a direction of an open government."  

Related Links:


  1. "When you see that trading is done, not by consent, but by compulsion- When you see that in order to produce, you need to obtain permission from men who produce nothing- when you see that money is flowing to those who deal, not in goods, but in favors- when you see that men get richer by graft and by pull than by work, and your laws don’t protect you against them, but protect them against you- when you see corruption being rewarded and honesty becoming a self-sacrifice- you may know that your society is doomed." Ayn Rand

  2. The corruption is so thick in the USA, it's becoming surreal. Good luck to Californians Aware organization! directed me to this webpage.

    1. Time to throw the bums out...

    2. I wonder how the Brown Act applies to the Sacramento City and County meetings over the new proposed Kings Arena, particularly regarding the billions of dollars in parking fees they are selling.

  3. Every single judge in California is OK and in bed with MERS real estate title fraud.

    Every single judge in California therefore needs to go to prison, immrediately.

  4. The solution is coming from fulldisclosure to inform people. My part of help is to go to a place to make a sign as: WWW.FULLDISCLOSURE.NET and attach to the back of my car's window. In the beginning of this blog address I draw a scale on the right position and to the end a scale on the opposite way.